Sober without god. An atheist / agnostic / humanist thread. Please be respectful!

I needed to read this to finally understand why small talk is so exhausting for me. Thank you, Menno, for sharing! @Mno

Complexity seems to be scary for many people. For me, it’s crucial to live in an environment that allows and maybe even appreciates complexity. I am a complex human being. I don’t want to have to fit in the black / white patterns of most people‘s minds.

4 Likes

Have any of you ever recommended this place to a friend IRL to help with their sobriety? If so, how has that worked out? Would you recommend this place for a real life friend?

3 Likes

I did recommend it once and then deleted my profile and made a new one. I didnt want that person to read my old posts but honestly I doubt that person is here.

If someone would ask me for advice about getting and staying sober I might recommend this app (and other things) but there is huge possibility I would disappear again and become more incognito :disguised_face:. There is one person who could really use this place cause he’s struggling a lot but unfortunately he doesn’t speak English (it’s my cousin). Otherwise I would definitely tell him to join us (and keep my current profile as it is).

I was thinking a lot about telling my husband to join this app (he’s an addict) but as mean as it sound, I don’t want to give up on this place for him. There is no way we could be both active here so it’s him or me. He has to find his own way. I have no other recovery related group. Sounds egoistic, I know, but I must protect my sobriety first. He doesn’t sound like he wants to quit anyway, he say he has it under control.

Making long answer short: yes, I would recommend this app is someone would ask me for advice. But I’m far far away from giving advices if not asked.

10 Likes

I saw a few of your posts and thought of this!

As a non-religious/non-spiritual person I find this list to be worthy of striving towards on a daily basis :smiling_face_with_sunglasses::call_me_hand:

7 Likes

Thanks Alex! I forgot to post that one :sweat_smile:

1 Like

I’ve talked about this place with my old friends. But none of them has a desire to stop. Guess I was the worst addict of 'm all. Well, that’s not quite true. Some of 'm just think they can’t live without booze. Anyhow, they have no interest in recovery communities.

In my work I talk about recovery a lot. About my own re/discovery in particular. I mention this place. Explain what it is and why it’s my number one place for peer support. I’m sure some of my patients/clients had a look and some became members. I don’t think many (if any) stuck around.

I don’t talk about my patients here anyhow. That’d be very unprofessional. I do talk about myself, and I am mostly an open book here, just like in my normal life, in my professional life as well. But I am somewhat cautious about sharing the most personal intimate details.

There’s some rather intimate stuff in the lounge, and I guess when people are involved enough here to be allowed in there, well they can know that too. In the end I am me and I don’t want to have secrets. I had way too much secrets for way too long. Made for a very unhappy life.

8 Likes

Thanks for your replies @poppyfairy @Mno

The reason I asked this question was because my partner has a FB acquaintance who made a post asking for help to get sober. Having seen the positive effect that this place has had on me she made a suggestion to me about introducing him to here. I had a couple of reservations so it didn’t happen.

When I was 18 I had a colleague who I worked behind a bar with. He was a great bartender, the kinda guy who could earn the nickname of octopus because he could do about 8 things at once. At the time I also had a factory job in a snack food factory, the bartending for me was just part time at the weekends to earn a little extra money.
He was looking for a job with full time hours and so when a position arose I told him about it and he applied. My manager asked me about him and I gave him a ringing endorsement, and he got the job.
Unfortunately within weeks he let me down. He was absent a lot and performance levels weren’t very good and he got sacked.

Since then I’ve never really recommended anyone for anything.

7 Likes

Trust your gut here. I have recommended this place to a few people and have shared my personal thread details. I have no idea if those people joined and are following my journey from the shadows (if so, hey guys!) but if they are it is probably rather eye opening. I am a pretty private person in the real world so this is my sanctuary to practice speaking honestly. So much of addiction (for me) is hiding. The practice of being myself is leaking out into my day to day life but I consider this place fairly sacred for my recovery. If I felt that the person I was recommending the site to might jeopardize my enjoyment of the site I would hesitate. If I felt they would enhance the site then yes, I’d share my details.

7 Likes

Thanks @TrustyBird

Good points you make. I was recommended this app by 2 people in a post I made on a sobriety group on FB. At the time I didn’t know there was a community here and wasn’t really looking for one. I wonder if those people who recommended this place are regular users of this community, if so, Hi and thank you again.

This place has an advantage over sobriety communities on social media because the rules are pretty straightforward and the place is moderated by people and not AI. The community also isn’t that stacked with regular users so it’s not too big, and the folks here tend to police it too. Trolls can be quickly dealt with too.

I think I would recommend this place to friends who are struggling with addiction but only with certain strings attached. I’d vet them first and tell them how it all works.

6 Likes

You asked such an interesting question that I’ve had to think about it for ages before I could come up with my thoughts.

The fact is that this app is good for anyone seeking support and sobriety. Absolutely.

The problematic side is a ME problem not a TS problem and I think that’s made me see maybe a defect or a trait or two that I really need to work on. I would be so worried I had been mean or offensive, self centred or just plain repulsive in my written narrative and presence that I would feel shame and certain fear. I feel I would be more like @poppyfairy and bolt just to erase any chance of negative exposure.

I’m not a fraud and I don’t lie, it’s not that. It’s just that I feel a certain remoteness here that allows anonymity and freedom to my voice. My irrational fears are that I could upset someone with my words should they read my thread. Perhaps I would invite them, and delete my personal thread, I dunno.

I definitely have a few personal realisations here to unpack. Main takeaways:

Don’t write what you wouldn’t want that person to read IRL…
Is it necessary to write/say?
Is it just being a main character without checking tone and compassion?
Could you attempt to reframe your thoughts and say it to their face instead of writing it into an APP online?

Honesty can be cruel if not executed with self awareness of your own responsibility and contribution to any given situation.

I need to revisit my shame and safety triggers and wounds because I always default to I AM GONNA GET REALLY HURT FOR THIS.

Be kind, always

Like I said, a ME problem. This place truly helped me heaps.

9 Likes

I want to be very careful with this quote. The power of it is in the last sentence. This is from the AA Grapevine magazine in 1977. I will add an edit to make it in keeping with this thread.

Whether I conceive of … as a set of immutable cosmic laws or as an old man with a white robe and matching beard (or a figment of human imagination) is totally and gloriously irrelevant. All that matters are my values and attitudes and how I act upon them.

All that matters are my values and attitudes and how I act upon them. Bang on.

2 Likes

You have an interesting topic here. I have struggled myself also with this question. This is like a safe place so the first tought is that I don’t want to share it with everyone.

I don’t know that how many of you have publicly shared that you are an alcoholic and therefore cannot drink at all. I myself am a bit discreet person and don’t want to shout it out loud. Maybe I am afraid that what the people will think of and how they will react and how will they see me after it.

But afterall I believe in honesty and openness so maybe I should rise a level higher and talk openly why I cannot drink. I queas nothing bad will happen. It’s ME problem and I am worrying too much what other people think pf it.

That said and processed I quess I might recommend this commmunity to someone who truly seeks aid. But this is kind of selfhelp place, so you must want to get better yourself before this community can be of any help.

3 Likes

I conceive god as nonexistent. As a figment of the imagination. And therefore as utterly irrelevant. That’s also the point of this thread Dan. While I agree with your last sentence, the rest of your post is of no importance or consequence in this thread. Read the first paragraph of the thread for that please.

3 Likes

That’s sort of basic for all sort of help isn’t it? So many people who are admitted to the clinic I work at are not sure they want to quit. So it doesn’t help. BTW, my experiences with substance abuse are part of my work, so I talk about my substance abuse lots. Outside my work when it comes up I tell. I don’t call myself an addict. Don’t like the word. Stigmatic.

4 Likes

Yeah I agree. And in every language the word is or words are a bit different. In Finland the word alcoholic is used quite lot. It really aint so beautiful word. Nevertheless what ever word is used the truth is that I cannot drink at all and maybe the word should not mean so much itself than the pure truth.

I quesa alcoholic means in some sentence a man who cannot drink at all or he drinks it all. That’s me basicly whether the word is ugly or not. But oh I understand you very well. I quess my second year could teach me a bit more openness and honesty and to be able to share this sickness to others. Not everyone but those who I see worthy of it or if I am asked about it on some occasion.

4 Likes

The words addict and addiction are interesting words in Dutch. It’s verslaafde and verslaafd, literally meaning (someone who is) enslaved. Enslaved to drugs, alcohol, gambling, etcetera. Again rather stigmatic words, but fitting to what the meaning is.

7 Likes

That would make an interesting topic to study different languages and the words and meaning and hidden messages behind them.

3 Likes

A very interesting topic!

In German, „addicted“ is „süchtig“.

But there‘s also „abhängig“, which would be translated in the term „dependent“.

3 Likes

I had a feeling that the quote was crossing a line. The part about being responsible for one’s attitudes and actions really resonates with me. I could have presented that, even awkwardly, out of context of the original quote. I went back and read your first post on the thread, and I will respect that going forward. Thanks for keeping me on track, Menno.

7 Likes

really interesting topic, because in Hebrew

Addicted = _machur_ *מָכוּר* for masculine,

_mechura_ *מְכוּרָה* for feminine

Root is MACHUR מ-כ-ר, same as “sold” — like you’re sold out to something.

and that is exactly how I feel in active addition

5 Likes